ABI
  1. ABI
  2. ABI-7523

When trying to site this unit, the wheel has come off because of a missing washer, this has caused damage to the chassis and also the bedroom floor

    Details

    • Type: Chassis (8 Weeks) Chassis (8 Weeks)
    • Status: Complete
    • Priority: High High
    • Resolution: Completed
    • Labels:
      None
    • Responsibility:
      Manufacturer Attending
    • Hire_or_Retail:
      Retail
    • Serial:
      1731105
    • Manufacturer:
      ABI
    • Model:
      Oakley
    • Year:
      2016
    • Size:
      36x12x3
    • ID Number:
      W0006233 W0006402
    • Status Colour:
      Complete Complete
    • Stock_Number:
      31602
    • Times Scheduled:
      1
    • Park_Company:
       Valley Caravan Park
    • Park_Postcode:
      PL27 6SS
    • Park_Contact:
      Martin Taylor
    • Park_Phone:
      01208 862391
    • Park_Email:
      info@valleycaravanpark.co.uk
    • Park_Code:
      VALL01
    • Park_Key_Account:
      Yes
    • SLA Status:
    1. ABI Ack.png
      103 kB
    2. address update.png
      81 kB
    3. collection of parts.png
      93 kB
    4. Completion by ABI.png
      128 kB
    5. e-mail to ABI regarding the rejection.png
      90 kB
    6. IMG_2996.JPG
      11 kB
    7. IMG_2997.JPG
      11 kB
    8. IMG_2998.JPG
      10 kB
    9. IMG_2999.JPG
      8 kB
    10. IMG_3001.JPG
      10 kB
    11. IMG_3002.JPG
      10 kB
    12. IMG_3003.JPG
      9 kB
    13. IMG_3004.JPG
      8 kB
    14. IMG_3005.JPG
      8 kB
    15. list of parts.png
      117 kB
    16. parts ordered.png
      105 kB
    17. parts required.png
      116 kB
    18. rejection .png
      94 kB
    19. reported to Tim and Sarah by e-mail.png
      99 kB
    20. response.png
      83 kB
    21. Submitted claim.png
      86 kB

      Activity

      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) created issue -
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Field Original Value New Value
      Park_Contact Mr Clemo
      Park_Postcode PL26 7AP
      Park_Phone 0172673533
      Park_Code Vall01
      Park_Key_Account No
      Park_Address2 London Apprentice
      Park_City St Austell
      Park_Address Pentewan Road,
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment IMG_2996.JPG [ 107208 ]
      Attachment IMG_2997.JPG [ 107209 ]
      Attachment IMG_2998.JPG [ 107210 ]
      Attachment IMG_2999.JPG [ 107211 ]
      Attachment IMG_3001.JPG [ 107212 ]
      Attachment IMG_3002.JPG [ 107213 ]
      Attachment IMG_3003.JPG [ 107214 ]
      Attachment IMG_3004.JPG [ 107215 ]
      Attachment IMG_3005.JPG [ 107216 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      e-mailed photographs to Tim Paker and ABI
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - e-mailed photographs to Tim Paker and ABI
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      Tim at ABI has asked for the delivery date. I have responded that this was delivered in mid October
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - Tim at ABI has asked for the delivery date. I have responded that this was delivered in mid October
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      Tim asked why the wheel didn't come off when the van was unloaded, I have advised that I don't know the answer to that, but assume that it might need to work it's way loose.
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - Tim asked why the wheel didn't come off when the van was unloaded, I have advised that I don't know the answer to that, but assume that it might need to work it's way loose.
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Park_Company Valley Valley Caravan Park
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Park_Contact Mr Clemo Martin Taylor
      Park_Postcode PL26 7AP PL27 6SS
      Park_Phone 0172673533 01208 862391
      Park_Code Vall01 VALL01
      Park_Address2 London Apprentice
      Park_City St Austell Polzeath
      Park_Address Pentewan Road, Valley Caravan Park
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment Submitted claim.png [ 107220 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Open [ 1 ] Submitted [ 10001 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Priority Normal [ 21 ] Critical [ 24 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Submitted [ 10001 ] Awaiting Customer Info [ 10012 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      ABI have rejected this issue, but I do not agree with the decision and have gone back and asked them to take another look at it prior to me updating the site.
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - ABI have rejected this issue, but I do not agree with the decision and have gone back and asked them to take another look at it prior to me updating the site.
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      RE: Rejection ABI Oakley 1731105 dispatch date August 2015
      wheel falling off and causing damage to the holiday home

      This is a really tricky one, I understand ABI not accepting this as the van was dispatched in August 2015, however this is a case where the van was unloaded and stayed in the same spot until they have decided to put the unit on the pitch.

      As I am no expert on the workings of a chassis, I have now shown the photographs to our siting team and they have advised that, in this instance, it does appear that there is evidence to show washer was missing. (in fact as I handed the pictures to them without even having time to tell them what they were looking at, I was advised that the wheel had come off because no washer had been fitted)

      Apparently, the metal shaft is showing signs of rounding off which is a tell tale sign that there has been movement of the wheel without a washer. They have stated that they would expect to see remains of the washer between the bolt and the metal shaft if it had been present, there is no evidence of this on these photographs.

      I next asked the question, would the wheel not have fallen off during delivery if the washer was missing and I have been informed that this isn’t always the case and that it is quite reasonable for the wheel to work its way off after several movements of the unit.

      With this in mind, please could you review this decision, prior to me confirming the rejection with the site.

      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - RE: Rejection ABI Oakley 1731105 dispatch date August 2015 wheel falling off and causing damage to the holiday home This is a really tricky one, I understand ABI not accepting this as the van was dispatched in August 2015, however this is a case where the van was unloaded and stayed in the same spot until they have decided to put the unit on the pitch. As I am no expert on the workings of a chassis, I have now shown the photographs to our siting team and they have advised that, in this instance, it does appear that there is evidence to show washer was missing. (in fact as I handed the pictures to them without even having time to tell them what they were looking at, I was advised that the wheel had come off because no washer had been fitted) Apparently, the metal shaft is showing signs of rounding off which is a tell tale sign that there has been movement of the wheel without a washer. They have stated that they would expect to see remains of the washer between the bolt and the metal shaft if it had been present, there is no evidence of this on these photographs. I next asked the question, would the wheel not have fallen off during delivery if the washer was missing and I have been informed that this isn’t always the case and that it is quite reasonable for the wheel to work its way off after several movements of the unit. With this in mind, please could you review this decision, prior to me confirming the rejection with the site.
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment rejection .png [ 107369 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      Sarah asked me to resend the photographs and she will take advice and get back to me.
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - Sarah asked me to resend the photographs and she will take advice and get back to me.
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Awaiting Customer Info [ 10012 ] Submitted [ 10001 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Submitted [ 10001 ] Awaiting Customer Info [ 10012 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      ABI have asked me to confirm whether this unit is at Winkleigh or in Cornwall, I have confirmed that the unit is in Cornwall at Valley Caravan Park
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - ABI have asked me to confirm whether this unit is at Winkleigh or in Cornwall, I have confirmed that the unit is in Cornwall at Valley Caravan Park
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment ABI Ack.png [ 107605 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      ID Number W0006233
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment address update.png [ 107608 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Awaiting Customer Info [ 10012 ] Submitted [ 10001 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Submitted [ 10001 ] Acknowledged [ 10005 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      I have phoned Valley and left a message for Lynne to let her know that ABI will be coming down to the van next week ( to assess the damage)
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - I have phoned Valley and left a message for Lynne to let her know that ABI will be coming down to the van next week ( to assess the damage)
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      ABi would like to collect the wheel from Valley, I will check with the site that they are happy for this to happen.
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - ABi would like to collect the wheel from Valley, I will check with the site that they are happy for this to happen.
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment collection of parts.png [ 107831 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment response.png [ 107832 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      I have phoned Valley CP and they have confirmed that the ABI engineer called in today, and took photographs etc and has collected the wheel - I have updated Sarah at ABI accordingly
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - I have phoned Valley CP and they have confirmed that the ABI engineer called in today, and took photographs etc and has collected the wheel - I have updated Sarah at ABI accordingly
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      ID Number W0006233 W0006233
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment parts required.png [ 108200 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      E-mail received advising that parts are required
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - E-mail received advising that parts are required
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Priority Critical [ 24 ] High [ 23 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment parts ordered.png [ 108229 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      1.SILVER FOIL
      2. JOISTING TIMBER
      1
      Repair LOCKERS TO COME DOWN TO CHANGE WALLBOARDS,
      FLOOR IN RIGHT CORNER WHERE
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - 1.SILVER FOIL 2. JOISTING TIMBER 1 Repair LOCKERS TO COME DOWN TO CHANGE WALLBOARDS, FLOOR IN RIGHT CORNER WHERE
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      ID Number W0006233 W0006233 W0006402
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment list of parts.png [ 108298 ]
      Hide
      Claire Folland added a comment -
      phoned site to advise ABI have ordered parts, they have advised they close on Friday and do not re-open until 4th Jan
      Show
      Claire Folland added a comment - phoned site to advise ABI have ordered parts, they have advised they close on Friday and do not re-open until 4th Jan
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Acknowledged [ 10005 ] Worksheet Issued [ 10004 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Times Scheduled 0 1
      Status Worksheet Issued [ 10004 ] Engineer Scheduled [ 10000 ]
      Work Scheduled 12/Jan/16
      Plot
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Attachment Completion by ABI.png [ 109737 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Engineer Scheduled [ 10000 ] Resolved [ 5 ]
      Resolution Completed [ 1 ]
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) made changes -
      Status Resolved [ 5 ] Complete [ 6 ]
      Hide
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment -
      ABI advise that this is complete.
      Show
      Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) added a comment - ABI advise that this is complete.
      Transition Time In Source Status Execution Times Last Executer Last Execution Date
      Open Open Submitted Submitted
      21m 10s 1 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 27/Nov/15 4:53 PM
      Submitted Submitted Awaiting Customer Info Awaiting Customer Info
      3d 18h 5m 2 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 02/Dec/15 3:00 PM
      Awaiting Customer Info Awaiting Customer Info Submitted Submitted
      2d 3h 30m 2 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 03/Dec/15 2:29 PM
      Submitted Submitted Acknowledged Acknowledged
      4s 1 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 03/Dec/15 2:29 PM
      Acknowledged Acknowledged Worksheet Issued Worksheet Issued
      48d 21h 12m 1 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 21/Jan/16 11:41 AM
      Worksheet Issued Worksheet Issued Engineer Scheduled Engineer Scheduled
      14s 1 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 21/Jan/16 11:41 AM
      Engineer Scheduled Engineer Scheduled Resolved Resolved
      53s 1 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 21/Jan/16 11:42 AM
      Resolved Resolved Complete Complete
      4s 1 Adrienne Barwell (Inactive) 21/Jan/16 11:42 AM

        People

        • Watchers:
          1 Start watching this issue

          Dates

          • Due:
            Created:
            Updated:
            Resolved:
            Work Scheduled: